Henryetta Free Lance
Login Subscribe Advertisers
Google Play App Store
  • News
    • Obituaries
    • Lifestyle
    • Opinion
  • Sports
  • E-edition
  • Public Notices
  • Calendar
  • Archives
  • Contact
    • Contact Us
    • Advertisers
    • Form Submission
    • About Us
    • News
      • Obituaries
      • Lifestyle
      • Opinion
    • Sports
    • E-edition
    • Public Notices
    • Calendar
    • Archives
    • Contact
      • Contact Us
      • Advertisers
      • Form Submission
      • About Us
After slow start, state to probe convictions involving debunked hair analysis
News
April 3, 2020
After slow start, state to probe convictions involving debunked hair analysis

A stray hair found at a crime scene and matched by microscope to hair from a suspect may be a good plot turn in a TV crime show. But in real life that forensic science hasn’t been used in decades – it’s been debunked. The newest plot turn in Oklahoma is that authorities are now trying to redress any wrongful convictions that occurred decades ago because of heavy reliance on microscopic hair analysis. The Oklahoma State Bureau of Investigation is working with district attorneys and others to examine about seven dozen cases and determine if they should be reopened, possibly leading to reversal of the conviction and release of people from prison. DNA testing of old hair samples also could affirm the conviction. Officials would not release names, details or locations of the cases, saying it’s not clear if defendants would want to have their cases reopened. But attorneys said the cases involve serious or violent crimes, including murder, accessory to murder and rape. “The OSBI anticipates this project will have a profound impact on the criminal justice community in Oklahoma,” the agency said in its application for a $477,539 federal grant in fiscal 2018 that was awarded and is funding the case-review process. “Using DNA to confirm the identity of a subject in a case or identify those wrongly convicted due to hair comparisons that have been deemed fallible will allow the criminal justice community to provide justice for both the victims and subjects in these cases.” Oklahoma is one of 10 states that received FBI letters in 2016 after the FBI reviewed cases in which the agency’s crime lab and its experts for microscopic hair comparisons were used, said Ryan Porter, a criminalist supervisor at OSBI’s forensic biology unit. A 2015 Innocence Project review of exonerations found 74 cases in 20 states involved microscopic hair analysis or testimony that was invalidated or improper. Ten of the exonerations came in Oklahoma. The OSBI’s effort to review the old cases got off to a slow start, largely because it was using volunteers. That changed after the federal grant allowed the OSBI to hire temporary employees, pay overtime and buy computers for the project. The grant will also pay for DNA testing of evidence in cases flagged in the review. Using guidance from the FBI, Oklahoma is undertaking the first batch of post-conviction reviews in state cases that used microscopic hair analysis before 2000. Much of the early focus is on whether expert witnesses or prosecutors exaggerated the associations between microscopic hair samples and whether the jury gave the evidence too much weight in its decision to convict. “In the process of reviewing that, they found several of their hair comparison analysts had actually trained people throughout the nation,” Porter said at a recent District Attorneys Council meeting. “Some of their analysts were making very strong statements about the comparison or match between the hair found at the scene or the suspect. “(Microscopic) hair comparison is basically debunked at this point. It is not good science, and the OSBI quit doing hair comparisons in 1999 or 2000. We decided that was not the way to go and we take hairs

City advances infrastructure projects
A: Main, Main...
City advances infrastructure projects
December 21, 2025
The Henryetta City Council convened for its regular meeting on Tuesday, Dec. 16, at the Henryetta Civic Center, opening with prayer and the Pledge of Allegiance before moving through a full agenda foc...
this is a test
A: Main
Property tax deadline extended
December 19, 2025
Okmulgee County Treasurer Lindsay Bunch is reminding property owners that the deadline to make property tax payments has been extended, while also sharing details on upcoming courthouse closures and t...
this is a test
Lions’ Christmas Basket project reflects over 70 years of community service
A: Main, Main...
Lions’ Christmas Basket project reflects over 70 years of community service
December 19, 2025
Long before delivery lines stretched across parking lots and long before hundreds of baskets were packed in a single day, the Henryetta Lions Club Christmas Basket Project lived quietly in the hearts ...
this is a test
Wreathing ceremony honors fallen Trooper Larry Smith
A: Main
Wreathing ceremony honors fallen Trooper Larry Smith
December 19, 2025
Each holiday season, remembrance takes on a quieter, more personal form for the Oklahoma Highway Patrol. This year, that remembrance led several troopers and family members to a graveside in Okmulgee ...
this is a test
News
Commissioners review bids for road project
December 19, 2025
A significant cost difference between competing bids for a major District 3 road project dominated discussion during Monday morning’s regular meeting of the Okmulgee County Board of Commissioners, as ...
this is a test
100 Years Ago (1925)
News
100 Years Ago (1925)
December 19, 2025
• A new weekly paper, The Henryetta News, published its first issue on Dec. 11. Edited by Rev. A. R. Garrett, a Baptist minister and former editor of the Dewar News, the publication announced plans to...
this is a test

e-Edition
ePaper
coogle_play
app_store
Editor Picks
Harlan Ford Toy Drive Wrapping Up with Strong Community Support
News
Harlan Ford Toy Drive Wrapping Up with Strong Community Support
December 19, 2025
The 10th Annual Harlan Ford Toy Drive is wrapping up its final days with an outpouring of generosity from across Okmulgee County, ensuring local foster children will experience a brighter Christmas mo...
this is a test
News
HOROSCOPES
December 19, 2025
ARIES – Mar 21/Apr 20 Aries, you have been looking for some new ways to make some extra money, and now might be the time to start putting your plan in motion.Good fortune awaits.TAURUS – Apr 21/May 21...
this is a test
Lady Demons show fight in home loss
News, Sports
Lady Demons show fight in home loss
December 19, 2025
The Beggs Lady Demons continued to show growth and grit Friday night inside Demon Dome, battling a deep and disciplined Metro Christian Lady Patriots squad before falling 59-27 in a regular-season mat...
this is a test
Season Tips Off with early momentum
News
Season Tips Off with early momentum
December 19, 2025
The 2025-26 high school basketball season is underway across Okmulgee County, and early results point to a winter filled with competitive matchups, developing talent and championship aspirations. As t...
this is a test
Bulldogs finding their rhythm
News
Bulldogs finding their rhythm
December 19, 2025
The Okmulgee Bulldogs, led by Head Coach Cordell Love, have opened the season at 1-2, highlighted by a recent strong win over Beggs. With a deep roster and a large group of returning upperclassmen, Ok...
this is a test
Facebook

HENRYETTA FREE-LANCE
208 E. Main Street
Henryetta, OK 74437

918.652.3311

This site complies with ADA requirements

© 2022 Henryetta Free-Lance

  • Contact
  • Privacy
  • Accessibility Policy